Seal of the State of Ohio. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page. The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page. Line Drawing of the Ohio Judicial Center. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page.
Spacer image

The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System

Issues Accepted for Review

About |  Help
Download PDFadobe icon

  All open cases and cases closed in past 180 days.
Case No.Case CaptionCase StatusDate
Accepted
Case Issue
2016-0636 Anthony Rush and Tammy Rush v. University of Cincinnati Physicians, Inc., and Thomas John Kunkel, M.D., and West Chester Medical Center et al. OPEN 7/27/2016 PROPOSITION OF LAW I: IN ANY TORT ACTION, THE EMPLOYEE DOES NOT NEED TO BE JOINED IN ORDER TO ESTABLISH RESPONDEAT SUPERIOR LIABILITY SO NAMEDA ASN DT HE EMPLOYER HAS BEEN PROPERLY SERVED. [National Union Fire Ins. Co. v. Wuerth, 122 Ohio St. 3d 594, 2009-Ohio-3601, 913 N.E. 2d 939, limited; Taylor 1:. Belmont Community Hosp., 71'" Dist., Belmont No. 09 BE 30, 2010-Ohio-3986, approved].
2016-0593 U.S. Bank, N.A. v. Lloyd E. Christmas et al. CLOSED 7/27/2016 If standing is challenged, is a party seeking to foreclosure a mortgage based on a defaulted promissory note is required to demonstrate an interest in both the note and the mortgage?
2016-0585 Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company v. Christine Lucarell OPEN 7/27/2016 Proposition Of Law No. I: Ohio law does not allow an award of punitive damages for breach of contract, although punitive damages may be available for any independent tort claims arising from related conduct.
2016-0585 Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company v. Christine Lucarell OPEN 7/27/2016 Proposition Of Law No. II: Prevention of performance is not a defense to the enforcement of a party's executed releases of liability.
2016-0585 Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company v. Christine Lucarell OPEN 7/27/2016 Proposition Of Law No. III : A court of appeals has the obligation to reach an assignment of error that is not mooted or forfeited.
2016-0585 Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company v. Christine Lucarell OPEN 7/27/2016 Proposition Of Law No. IV: A plaintiff cannot base a fraudulent inducement claim on representations that are speculative, inconsistent with a written agreement, and upon which the plaintiff did not rely.
2016-0570 State of Ohio v. James E. Schroeder OPEN
(Held)
7/27/2016 Proposition of Law: To impose valid post release control, the language in the sentencing must correctly state the duration and mandatory or discretionary nature of the sanction. The entry may not simply incorporate the advisements given during the sentencing hearing by referencing the post release control statute.
2016-0564 Michael Gyugo v. Franklin County Board of Developmental Disabilities OPEN 7/27/2016 Proposition of Law: Applicants with criminal convictions that have been expunged pursuant to R.C. 2953.32 are not obliged to disclose those convictions in response to questions posed in violation ofR.C. 2953.33(B)(l)
2016-0490 State of Ohio v. Maurice Gales OPEN
(Held)
7/27/2016 PROPOSITION OF LAW: A DEFENDANT WHO COMMITS AN OFFENSE PRIOR TO JULY 1, 1996 IS SUBJECT TO LAW IN EFFECT AT THE TIME OF THE OFFENSE AND NOT SUBJECT TO SENTENCING PROVISIONS OF H.B. 86 EFFECTIVE SEPTEMBER 30, 2011.
2016-0441 State of Ohio v. Buddy Mutter OPEN 6/15/2016 FIRST PROPOSITION OF LAW: Second prosecutions are barred when they require relitigation of factual issues already resolved by a previous prosecution. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, United States Constitution; Section 10, Article I, Ohio Constitution.
12345678910...
Case Issue Votes
lbCaseNumber

lbCaseCaptionShort

lbCaseIssueDescription